Logic Lesson: How to identify a second-rate person

Italian member of the Parliament Gabriella Carlucci is giving logic lessons. Today’s lesson is the idea that: Anyone who does not have a Nobel Prize is at best second-rate.

Carlucci has been making speeches and writing letters disparaging the work of Italian physicist Luciano Maiani. Carlucci, who does not yet have a Nobel Prize, sent the following letter to Nobel Prize winner (and Luciano Maiani’s research collaborator) Sheldon Glashow:

Dear Prof. Glashow,

You wrote to the President Prodi brutally insulting me, yet—without getting to the substance of things.

I inform you that the contents of the letter that caused your anger come from news published on italian newspapers, on Nature and “Lettere al Nuovo Cimento” [an italian-scientific publication of secondary importance, ndt]. News that were never disproven. I write to you only now to ask you one simple question:

If Maiani and his friends are, as you say, stellar luminaries highly esteemed throughout the world, why did they never win a Nobel prize ? Yet, italian Particle Physics (and in particular that in Rome) is in percentage and absolute value among the best financed in the world.

I hope you will answer without insulting me. And do not tell lies: I could surprise you.


Gabriella Carlucci.

That letter (actually, this translation of that letter) appears on a detailed history of Gabriella Carlucci’s adventure, prepared by physicist Tommaso Dorigo. For a more concise history, see the Gravitas Free Zone Weblog.

(Thanks to investigator Giovanni Peccati for bringing this to our attention.)

Comments are closed.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!