The ‘Singing Cymbal’ controversy

The photo above is a still from a CERN teaching resources video (2014).

“Use a cymbal or metallic plate that can vibrate freely. Use a flash, for example from a camera, hold it close to the plate and flash. You will hear a low tone.

Physics: The moment of the photons are transferred in an inelastic collision to the atoms of the cymbal. This can also be used as an example of energy conversion.”

Not so fast, say Thomas R Moore, Samantha Collin and Nikki Etchnique of the Department of Physics at Rollins College in their paper ‘The singing cymbal : Is it really photon momentum?’ 

“Although it has been generally accepted that this is a demonstration of the effects of photon momentum, and the idea promulgated by a world-class institution such as CERN, this does not necessarily make it so.”

Their experimental and theoretical study found that the cymbal does indeed ‘sing’ – but primarily from heating and acoustic effects caused by the camera flash. Only a tiny fraction of the vibration, they say, is due to photon momentum transfer effects – equivalent to dropping just one grain of salt onto the cymbal (with inaudible results).

NOTE: Unfortunately, CERN’s ‘Singing Cymbal’ experiment is now off-line – but an archive from 2014 is available here. The video itself is available in a somewhat obsolete format (.rm) here.

113 Responses to “The ‘Singing Cymbal’ controversy”

  1. facebook proxies Says:

    I absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be what precisely I’m looking for. Does one offer guest writers to write content in your case? I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write in relation to here. Again, awesome web log!

  2. get private proxies Says:

    It’s really a nice and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  3. Can you hear me now Says:

    This guy has something very important to say!

  4. Couple has the best seat in the house Says:

    These two sure know how to enjoy a movie!

  5. Couple in movie theater Says:

    This has to be the happiest couple on planet Earth!

  6. Old guy reads the newspaper on a beautiful sunny day Says:

    Nothing relaxes him like reading does.

  7. Even doctors like chocolate Says:

    Nothing is more relaxing than eating chocalate!

  8. The future of kitty cats Says:

    This is what the future holds for kitty cats.

  9. Kitty Futurology Says:

    This is the future of kitty cats.

  10. He likes to be their first customer in the morning Says:

    Expect to see him when the restaurant opens every day.

  11. Doctor enjoying chocolate Says:

    Doctor bite right into a chococlate bar.

  12. Very cute kitty Says:

    Isn’t that a cute kitty?!

  13. guy waiting at door Says:

    He’s just waiting patiently for the place to open up.

Leave a Reply