Become a patron

“Dumbness” as a musically authentic asset (new study)


Hector Qirko is not only Associate Professor of Anthropology and Associate Department Chair at the College of Charleston, US – he’s also, as can be appreciated above, a recording artist.

As such, he’s noticed that when it comes to popular music, “dumbness” in performances can sometimes be regarded as a musically authentic asset.

“I once overheard a session producer compliment a musician for his ‘dumb’ contribution to a recording. Another time, I heard an engineer, listening to a track in preparation for mixing, praise the ‘good, stupid-sounding tone on that guitar.’ And in my own struggles to come up with a good approach to a song, a colleague once advised me to ‘play it dumber’.”

The professor’s newly published paper, in the journal Popular Music and Society, suggests that “dumbness” is a commonly shared concept that influences many aspects of musical production.

See : “Dumb” Performance as a Marker of Authenticity

If readers can suggest any particularly “dumb” performances that can serve to illustrate the point, please do get in touch.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!